Republicans of the #MAGA Cult were amused and downright giddy after Florida’s horrible governor tried to out-Trump Trump by flying 50 unsuspecting immigrants to Martha’s Vineyard to “own the libs.” It was a cruel act, and yet the #MAGA thinks the Ron DeSantis Airlift made a damning point about the Biden administration’s immigration and border policy. 

Again, the #MAGA and their provocateurs in right-wing media miss or ignore the stark dishonesty and short-sightedness of Trumpism, making them a party, in this case, to a cynical political prank.

All of this — from the treatment of human beings as political objects to the constant reference to them as “illegals” — serves to send a strong anti-immigrant message. 

Republicans will say they support immigration, as long as people from Central America enter the country through the channels established by law. But the Trump era represented a new hard line on immigrants: Refusing to work with Congress to reform national immigration policy; separating children from their families; demanding that asylum-seekers remain in dangerous conditions in Mexico while their applications are processed; betraying the DACA Dreamers; establishing a public charge test to refuse immigrants from what Trump called “shithole countries.” Numerous investigations by the press demonstrated that Trump adviser and white supremacist Stephen Miller pushed aggressive policies at the border less we face “the end of our country as we know it.”

All of this amounts to a strong anti-immigrant posture. That’s what the right wants. If too many Black and brown people enter the country and eventually reach a path to citizenship, it would be the end of the country’s white power structure. That’s what the #MAGA GOP fears. That was Miller’s point.

Not only is that approach appalling and racist, it’s self-defeating for the U.S. We do not have enough workers to fill all of the nation’s job openings, particularly in public education, health care and the leisure and hospitality industries. This was true even before the pandemic. Economists warned Trump that the country would never reach 4% annual growth without a new influx of immigrants. During Biden’s time in office, the nation has recouped some 20 million jobs, but The Washington Post reports severe worker shortages: We have 11 million job openings and only 6 million unemployed workers.

Hospitality and leisure are down 1.2 million jobs; public schools are missing 360,000 workers; health care has 37,000 openings and rail transportation is down 12,500 jobs since the pandemic. People are burning out and retiring early, and the country was already facing workforce challenges with the retirement of the baby boomers.

So, the #MAGA might think that Republican governors flying immigrants to Martha’s Vineyard — or busing them out of Texas and Arizona to the East Coast — is good for laughs. While intended to slap the Biden administration, it actually slaps Republicans with another layer of ugly nationalism and racism, and amplifies the message that immigrants are not wanted here even as we struggle to fill job openings.

3 thoughts on “Republicans again back immigrant cruelty even as the U.S. faces a severe worker shortage

  1. Excellent blog. A core reason for the current inflation is tied to the Republicans stupid racist immigration policy which has created a lack of entry level workers. It has however created full employment or close to it for chronically underemployed cohorts of people like Baltimore citizens. Evidence of that is seen in the low demand for workforce training at places like CFUF.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Granted, the Republicans are white supremacist, xenophobic, 2042-phobic, nativist, and everything else evil, unholy, and even worse, ill-logical. However, the Democrats closet their own hypocritical misgivings about immigration by failing to advocate for open borders. Democrats pay no or too little attention to one of the most basic of human rights: the right to self-determined freedom of movement and association. Labor mobility is democracy at its core. Democrats fall miserably on this despite having at their disposal the boomeranging against the Republicans the Republicans’ hallowed neo-liberal laissez-faire first commandment of capitalism: “Thy government shall not intervene in free markets except to abolish fetters on free markets.” For Democrats, the champions of “January 6th democracy,” open borders are too much democracy when it comes to non-Americans while at the same time Americans pretty much travel wherever their pocketbooks allow.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s